blog
What Are the Best Investments for Sequence of Returns Risk?
Last Updated: October 29, 2026
Quick Summary
The best investments for sequence of returns risk are layered defensive holdings: cash and Treasury bills covering one to three years of withdrawals, a short-to-intermediate Treasury or investment-grade bond ladder for years three through seven, TIPS for inflation protection, and a diversified stock portfolio for long-term growth. An income annuity can guarantee essential expenses underneath it all.
- Sequence risk is a cash-flow problem, addressed with structure rather than prediction.
- Cash and T-bills win on liquidity but lose on inflation over long holds.
- A five-year ladder of $40,000 rungs funds each year's spending without selling at a loss.
- Flexible withdrawal rules trim discretionary spending after a losing year instead of selling depressed assets.
- Place bonds and cash in tax-deferred accounts and growth assets in taxable accounts.
Table of Contents
- What Sequence of Returns Risk Means for Your Retirement Portfolio
- How to Protect Against Sequence of Returns Risk: A Comparison of Strategies
- The Cash Bucket Strategy for Retirement: Liquidity Without Selling Into a Downturn
- Building a Bond Ladder for Retirement Income
- Safe Withdrawal Strategy: Flexible Spending Rules That Extend Portfolio Longevity
- Asset Allocation and Diversification: Matching Investments to Your Time Horizon
- Tax Treatment and Account Location for Lower-Volatility Assets
- Building Your Retirement Income Plan With New Insight Financial
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Sequence of Returns Risk Means for Your Retirement Portfolio
Sequence of returns risk is the danger that the order in which your investment returns arrive, not their average, determines whether your retirement portfolio survives.
Many people in their late fifties and early sixties worry about average returns, but far fewer think about the order of those returns.
Below, we compare the specific investments and strategies that address this risk, with the trade-offs each carries.
Why the Order of Returns Matters More Than the Average
A simple illustration explains it better than any definition. Suppose two portfolios both average 5% annually over 25 years.
The reason is mechanical. When you sell assets during a downturn to fund withdrawals, you lock in losses and permanently shrink the base that must generate future recovery.
According to the SEC's investor education guidance on asset allocation, the mix of investments you hold drives most of your portfolio's variability, which is why structure matters more than stock picking in the distribution phase. The FINRA retirement account guidance makes a related point: withdrawals during market declines can permanently reduce principal in ways deposits later cannot repair.
That is the core tension. You cannot control return order. You can control where your spending money comes from when returns turn negative.
How to Protect Against Sequence of Returns Risk: A Comparison of Strategies
Protecting against sequence-of-returns risk generally means holding enough stable, liquid assets to fund spending during a downturn so growth assets can stay invested.
The query asks for the best investments, and many discussions stop at naming strategies. A useful comparison is at the instrument level: which holdings do the defensive work, and what does each cost you in liquidity, inflation exposure, and long-term growth?
Comparing the Defensive Investments Side by Side
| Investment | Liquidity | Inflation Exposure | Main Risk | Role in a Sequence-Risk Plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash / money market | Highest, same day | High, purchasing power erodes | Reinvestment risk if rates fall | Funds 1-3 years of withdrawals |
| Treasury bills | High, short maturities, deep market | High over long holds | Low credit risk; reinvestment risk | Near-term rungs of a cash reserve |
| Short/intermediate Treasuries | High, actively traded | Moderate | Interest-rate risk if sold early | Stable middle-layer income |
| TIPS | High, actively traded | Low, principal adjusts with CPI | Real yields can be low; taxable phantom income | Inflation-protected spending floor |
| Investment-grade bond ladder | Moderate, hold to maturity | Moderate | Credit and reinvestment risk | Scheduled income rungs |
| Income annuity (SPIA) | Low, illiquid once purchased | Depends on contract; some offer CPI riders | Insurer credit risk; loss of control | Guaranteed essential-expense floor |
| Diversified stock portfolio | High, daily liquidity | Low over long horizons | Volatility and drawdown | Long-horizon growth engine |
Read the table by role, not by rank. No single row is "best." Cash and T-bills win on liquidity and lose on inflation. TIPS win on inflation protection and can lag in real yield. Annuities win on certainty and lose on flexibility. A diversified stock portfolio wins on long-run growth and is the asset most damaged by forced selling, which is exactly why the defensive rows exist.
The Trade-Offs Competitors Understate
- Cash and T-bills carry an opportunity cost. A reserve sized to two or three years of spending is insurance, not an investment; held for a decade, it can lag inflation and equity returns.
- Bonds carry three risks at once. Interest-rate risk, reinvestment risk, and inflation risk. A ladder spreads the first two but does not erase the third.
- TIPS are not free inflation protection. Real yields can be modest, and inflation adjustments in taxable accounts are taxed as income before you receive them.
How the Pieces Fit Together
A workable structure layers the instruments by when the money is needed:
- Years 1-2: cash and Treasury bills, so a market decline never forces a stock sale.
- Years 3-7: a short-to-intermediate Treasury or investment-grade ladder, plus TIPS if inflation protection matters.
- Years 8+: a diversified stock portfolio for growth, refilling the front layers after strong years.
- Essential expenses: an income annuity can sit underneath all of it, guaranteeing the floor so the rest of the plan can tolerate volatility.
A common mistake is picking one instrument and ignoring the rest. Cash alone does not protect a 30-year retirement. A bond ladder alone does not keep pace with inflation over decades. The strongest plans layer them so each covers the others' weak points.
The Cash Bucket Strategy for Retirement: Liquidity Without Selling Into a Downturn
The cash bucket strategy for retirement holds one to three years of expected withdrawals in cash or cash equivalents, so you never sell stocks during a decline just to pay bills. When markets fall, you spend from the bucket. When markets recover, you refill it.
The mechanics are simple:
- Bucket one: cash and short-term instruments covering near-term expenses
- Bucket two: bonds and other fixed income covering the middle years
- Bucket three: stocks and growth assets for the long horizon
The trade-off is real. Cash earns little, and holding too much over decades can leave you short of needed growth. We size the cash bucket to actual spending needs, not to a round number that feels safe.
Building a Bond Ladder for Retirement Income
A bond ladder for retirement income splits your fixed-income holdings into individual bonds maturing in successive years. Each maturing rung funds that year's spending, so you are not forced to sell longer-term holdings at a loss when rates move against you.

A Worked Example
Suppose a retiree needs $40,000 a year from the fixed-income sleeve to cover spending not met by Social Security and a pension. A five-year ladder might look like this:
| Rung (maturity) | Amount | Instrument | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $40,000 | Treasury bill or money market | Spending this year |
| Year 2 | $40,000 | 2-year Treasury note | Spending next year |
| Year 3 | $40,000 | 3-year Treasury note | Scheduled rung |
| Year 4 | $40,000 | 4-year Treasury note | Scheduled rung |
| Year 5 | $40,000 | 5-year Treasury note | Scheduled rung |
When the Year 1 rung matures, you spend it and buy a new 5-year rung at the far end, keeping the ladder's length constant. Cash arrives on schedule regardless of prices, so you never sell a longer bond at a loss to raise spending money.
Why It Helps With Sequence Risk
The ladder converts market timing into a calendar. In a year when stocks fall, the maturing rung funds spending and the equity portfolio stays untouched, the same logic as a cash bucket, extended several years out and typically at a higher yield than cash.
The Limits Deserve Equal Attention
- Inflation risk. Future rungs get reinvested at whatever rates prevail then. If inflation runs above the ladder's yields for years, each rung buys less. TIPS rungs can address this at the cost of lower starting real yields.
- Reinvestment risk. When rungs mature in a falling-rate environment, the replacement rung yields less, shrinking future income.
- Interest-rate risk on the longer rungs. Selling a long rung before maturity can mean a price below par when rates have risen.
For a step-by-step walkthrough of constructing one, see our guide on how to build a bond ladder for income.
Safe Withdrawal Strategy: Flexible Spending Rules That Extend Portfolio Longevity
A safe withdrawal strategy works best when it bends. A fixed withdrawal rate applied blindly through a bear market is one of the fastest routes to portfolio depletion.
The practical version: set a baseline withdrawal for normal years. After a strong year, allow a modest increase.
The catch is behavioral. For the mechanics, read our guide to dynamic withdrawal strategies for retirees, and for tactics during declines, see adjusting retirement spending during market downturns.
Asset Allocation and Diversification: Matching Investments to Your Time Horizon
Asset allocation and diversification are how you match investments to the time horizon of each spending goal. Money you need in two years belongs in stable assets. Money you need in twenty years belongs in growth assets.
A balanced portfolio spreads holdings across stocks, bonds, and cash so no single market event controls your outcome. The Federal Reserve's consumer resources on saving and investing notes that diversification reduces the impact of any one investment on overall results, though it cannot remove market risk entirely.
We build allocations around when money is needed, not around a target return. That shift changes how much volatility a retiree can actually tolerate.
Tax Treatment and Account Location for Lower-Volatility Assets
Where you hold lower-volatility investments can matter as much as holding them.
This is one of the angles most sequence-risk guides skip. The tax treatment of your stable assets affects how much of each withdrawal you actually keep. For a closer look, read can you manage retirement portfolio risk tax-efficiently.
Watch out: account placement decisions interact with required minimum distributions and Social Security timing. Do not optimize one in isolation.
Building Your Retirement Income Plan With New Insight Financial
A sequence-of-returns plan only works when it is built around your actual spending, accounts, and risk tolerance.
New Insight Financial offers personalized retirement planning strategies for individuals and couples, focused on mitigating major financial risks in retirement, including withdrawal and market risk.
If you are still a few years from retirement, planning can help you prepare for that transition. Learn more about our retirement strategy and risk assessment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is sequence of returns risk real?
Yes. Two retirees can earn the same average return over 25 years and end with very different balances if one experiences poor returns in the first few years of withdrawals. Early losses shrink the principal that later gains must compound on, and each withdrawal locks in part of that loss. The risk is highest in the five to ten years around your retirement date, which is why the investments you hold then matter as much as the returns you earn.
Are bonds or cash better for managing sequence risk?
They solve different problems. Cash reserves cover near-term expenses so you avoid selling stocks in a downturn, but cash loses purchasing power to inflation over long periods. A bond ladder for retirement income provides scheduled, predictable cash flow across several years and typically yields more than cash. Many retirees use both: a short cash reserve for one to two years of spending and a bond ladder covering the next several years, with stocks reserved for longer-term growth.
How does withdrawing money during a market downturn affect retirement savings?
A withdrawal during a downturn permanently removes shares at depressed prices, so those shares cannot participate in the recovery. A 10% decline plus a 4% withdrawal effectively removes about 14% of the portfolio, and the remaining balance must earn a higher return just to get back to even. Holding a cash bucket strategy for retirement and pausing or reducing flexible withdrawals during a bear market can soften that damage.
Can an annuity reduce sequence of returns risk?
A portion of your portfolio placed in a fixed or income annuity can create a predictable income floor, reducing how much you must withdraw from investments during bad markets. The trade-offs are giving up liquidity, locking in today's payout rates, and losing upside on that money. Whether it fits depends on your risk tolerance, other guaranteed income such as Social Security, and how much flexibility you want, so review the contract terms with a qualified professional before committing.
The hardest part of sequence-of-returns planning is not understanding it. It is committing to a structure before the next downturn tests it. New Insight Financial can help you build that structure now, with customized strategies, a personalized risk assessment, and Generational Vault® for your essential documents. Get started with New Insight Financial and put a plan in place that holds up when the order of returns turns against you.