Comparison
Roth Conversion vs Keeping Money in Traditional IRA
Last Updated: November 12, 2026
Quick Summary
A roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA and makes you pay income tax on the converted amount now. The choice weighs paying tax today against keeping tax-deferred growth. Conversions often make sense when your future tax rate is expected to be higher than today's rate.
- Traditional IRA withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, and required minimum distributions apply.
- Roth IRA qualified withdrawals are tax-free, with no lifetime RMDs for the original owner.
- Paying the conversion tax from outside cash generally works better than using IRA funds.
- The pro-rata rule treats all traditional IRAs as one pool for taxing conversions.
- Track your Form 8606 each year to know your after-tax basis before converting.
Table of Contents
- Roth Conversion vs Traditional IRA: How the Two Accounts Differ
- How Taxes Work When You Convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth
- When to Convert Traditional IRA to Roth and When to Keep It
- Roth Conversion Five-Year Rule, Deadlines and Reversibility
- Using a Traditional IRA to Roth Conversion Calculator for a Side-by-Side Comparison
- Checking Your Next Step With New Insight Financial
- Frequently Asked Questions
Roth Conversion vs Traditional IRA: How the Two Accounts Differ
A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA and makes you pay income tax on the converted amount now. Many people in their 50s and early 60s face this choice as they near retirement. The trade-off is between paying tax today and keeping tax-deferred growth in place. (Source: IRS Publication 590-B)
The two accounts work in opposite ways. A traditional IRA is funded with pre-tax dollars or deductible contributions, grows tax-deferred, and is taxed as ordinary income when you withdraw. Required minimum distributions also apply once you reach the required age (Retirement plan and IRA required minimum distributions FAQs). A Roth IRA is funded with after-tax dollars, and qualified withdrawals are tax-free, with no required minimum distributions for the original owner.
- Traditional IRA: Tax deferred now, taxable on withdrawal, required minimum distributions apply
- Roth IRA: Taxed now, qualified withdrawals tax-free, no lifetime RMDs for the original owner
- Roth conversion: Moves pre-tax funds into the Roth and triggers income tax in the year of the move
Schwab's Roth IRA conversion guide explains how the conversion process itself works. Read it alongside your own numbers before you move any money.
How Taxes Work When You Convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth
Converting a traditional IRA adds the converted amount to your taxable income for the year. The added income can push you into a higher federal tax bracket, and it can also affect how much of your Social Security benefits are taxed. You will pay the tax with money held outside the IRA when possible, since using IRA funds to pay the bill reduces what gets converted and may trigger a penalty.
Vanguard's Roth conversion resource covers the timing and tax considerations that come with moving pre-tax funds, including 401(k) balances.
Pro-Rata Rule and After-Tax IRA Basis
If you have made nondeductible contributions to a traditional IRA, part of your balance is after-tax basis. The pro-rata rule treats all of your traditional IRAs as one pool when you convert. Only the pre-tax share of the conversion is taxable, so a conversion will not be tax-free just because you made after-tax contributions. Track your Form 8606 each year so you know your basis before you convert.
The table below summarises the main tax points that come up when you convert a traditional IRA to a Roth.
| Factor | Effect | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Conversion amount | Added to taxable income for the year | Can push you into a higher bracket |
| Tax payment source | Paying from IRA funds reduces the conversion | Paying from outside cash is generally preferred |
| Nondeductible contributions | Create after-tax basis | Track on Form 8606 |
| Pro-rata rule | Treats all traditional IRAs as one pool | Only the pre-tax share is taxable |
| Social Security | Conversion income can affect how much is taxed | Review before converting |
When to Convert Traditional IRA to Roth and When to Keep It
The decision often comes down to a comparison: the tax rate you pay on the conversion today versus the tax rate that would apply to those same dollars when they come out of a traditional IRA later. Other factors such as bracket management, Medicare income thresholds, state taxes, and timing can shift that comparison. A conversion tends to make sense when the future rate is expected to be higher than today's rate, and keeping the money in a traditional IRA tends to make sense when the future rate is expected to be lower.
A break-even analysis makes the trade-off concrete. The inputs are your current marginal tax rate, your expected future marginal tax rate, the account balance, the number of years until withdrawal, and the source of the money used to pay the conversion tax. Paying the conversion tax from cash outside the IRA is often what makes the math work, because using IRA dollars to pay the tax reduces the amount that gets converted and, before age 59½, can trigger an additional 10% tax on the portion withheld.
Change the growth rate, the horizon, or the tax-payment source and the break-even point moves, which is why a single rule of thumb is unreliable. Working through a simplified example with your own assumptions will show how these inputs interact.
One pattern some people consider is converting in the years between retirement and the start of Social Security and required minimum distributions, when taxable income may be lower. Filling the lower brackets during that window can lock in a lower rate on money that would otherwise be taxed later at a higher rate. If your income is already high this year, the same conversion may cost more than it saves.
Keeping money in a traditional IRA may make sense when you expect a lower tax rate in retirement, when you have no cash outside the IRA to pay the conversion tax, when the conversion would push you past income-based thresholds such as Medicare premium surcharges or the taxation of Social Security benefits, or when you may need the money within a few years. Charitable intent also matters, and an advisor can review how beneficiary and charitable goals fit your overall plan. (Source: IRS Form 8606 instructions)
Watch out: because a conversion is generally irreversible, an unexpected income increase in the year of conversion can make it more expensive than you modeled.
Current vs. Future Tax Brackets
The decision often turns on whether you are in a lower bracket now than you expect to be later. Some people in their early retirement years, before Social Security and required distributions begin, have a window of lower taxable income. Converting during that window can fill lower brackets at a lower rate. If your income is already high this year, the same conversion may cost more.
Effects on Medicare Premiums and Income Thresholds
A conversion raises your modified adjusted gross income, which can increase the Medicare Part B and Part D premiums you pay later through income-related monthly adjustment amounts. Review the current Medicare income thresholds with an official source or a qualified advisor before converting.
State Taxes and Moving Between States
State income tax rules differ, and the rate you pay on a conversion depends on where you live when you convert. State income tax rules differ, and the cost of a conversion can vary depending on where you live when you convert. If you plan to move to a state with different tax rules, review how that change could affect the conversion.
Roth Conversion Five-Year Rule, Deadlines and Reversibility
Each conversion may have its own five-year clock before the converted amount can be withdrawn penalty-free if you are under age 59½. Confirm the current federal rules for the start date and qualified withdrawal conditions with the IRS or a qualified advisor.
Once you convert, the decision is generally permanent under current federal rules, so the planning happens before you move the money. Confirm the current rules on reversing a conversion with the IRS or a qualified advisor.
Using a Traditional IRA to Roth Conversion Calculator for a Side-by-Side Comparison
A calculator can be a useful way to compare keeping money in a traditional IRA with converting it, but the output is only as good as the assumptions you feed it. Free online Roth conversion calculators can estimate the future value of each path so you can see the trade-off with your own assumptions. Before you trust any result, know which inputs move the answer most: your current marginal tax rate, your expected future marginal tax rate, the number of years until withdrawal, the assumed growth rate, and whether the conversion tax is paid from outside cash or from the IRA itself.

A transparent side-by-side model has three columns: keep the traditional IRA, convert all at once, and convert in partial amounts over several years. For each column, project the balance forward at the same growth rate, then apply the expected future tax rate to traditional withdrawals and zero tax to qualified Roth withdrawals. Subtract the conversion tax paid from outside cash in the convert columns so the comparison is apples to apples. The partial-conversion column usually wins when a full conversion would push you into a higher bracket or across a Medicare income threshold, because spreading the income across years keeps each dollar in a lower bracket.
Run the numbers with your actual tax rate, your expected retirement tax rate, and the years until you plan to withdraw. Then test a partial conversion, which spreads the tax over several years. Review your timing and whether a conversion pays off for your situation, and consider a personal side-by-side model you can review with a qualified advisor.
Watch out: a calculator that ignores the source of the tax payment, the pro-rata rule on after-tax basis, or the two-year lookback on Medicare premiums can overstate the benefit of converting.
Taxes on retirement withdrawals interact with the conversion as well, so review those effects before you commit to a multi-year plan.
Checking Your Next Step With New Insight Financial
The right answer depends on your current bracket, your future income, your state, and whether conversion income affects your Medicare premiums. Start with a side-by-side estimate, then review the result with someone who can see your full picture. New Insight Financial offers personalized retirement planning built around your risk tolerance and timing. Get started today to see which account structure fits your retirement plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much tax will I pay on a $100,000 Roth IRA conversion?
The tax on a $100,000 conversion depends on how much of that money came from pre-tax contributions and on your total taxable income for the year. Pre-tax amounts are added to your ordinary income and taxed at your marginal federal rate, plus any state income tax. Money you already contributed after tax is generally not taxed again. Because the converted amount can push you into a higher bracket, the real cost is often higher than a simple percentage suggests. Running the numbers with a calculator or a financial professional before converting is the safest way to estimate your bill.
Can I convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA after age 72?
Yes, age does not block a Roth conversion. However, if you are already taking required minimum distributions, you must take that year's required distribution before converting, and the RMD amount itself cannot be converted. Converting late in retirement also leaves less time for tax-free growth to build up. Confirm the current federal RMD rules with the IRS or a qualified advisor.
How does the Roth IRA five-year rule apply to conversions?
Each Roth conversion may have its own five-year clock before converted amounts can be withdrawn penalty-free. Confirm the current federal rules for the start date, the early withdrawal penalty, and qualified distribution requirements with the IRS or a qualified advisor. Track each conversion year separately so you know when each portion becomes accessible.
What factors should I compare before converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA?
Start with your expected tax bracket now versus in retirement, and whether you can pay the conversion tax from non-IRA savings. Next, consider how the added income could affect Medicare Part B and D premiums, which use income thresholds, and whether you have after-tax basis that the pro-rata rule will affect. Also check your state income tax and any plans to move. Finally, consider your time horizon, estate goals and how much of the account you expect to leave to heirs.